Cookie Club › Oatmeal Butterscotch Image 1 of 1 Oatmeal Butterscotch $4.00 Not your grandmas oatmeal cookie. Hints of cinnamon, oatmeal and loaded with butterscotch. Add To Cart Added! Not your grandmas oatmeal cookie. Hints of cinnamon, oatmeal and loaded with butterscotch. You Might Also Like Apple Crisp (Vegan) $4.00 Brown Butter Toffee $4.00 Spooky Pebbles $4.00 Pumpkin Cheesecake $4.00 Salted Chocolate Chip $4.00